Killing sea lions to save salmon

By Patrick Cooney

I rubbed my eyes, focused, and asked: Is it Sasquatch? A massive beaver pushing a log? Or is it Humphrey the Wayward Whale up to his old shenanigans?

After spending much of my life in rivers around the globe, I had never seen such a large hairy beast plying freshwater like I did the other day while hiking alongside the Columbia River near Portland, Oregon. True, I have seen manatees, but they were not this large or hairy, plus manatees are subtropical. I grabbed my phone and snapped a few grainy photos…maybe it was the Loch Ness Monster!

Sea Lion Columbia River

I inspected the pictures, and it hit me. I was more than 100 miles from the nearest ocean, yet 150 feet in front of me was a fat 1,000+ pound male sea lion!

Why would a sea lion swim this far into freshwater?

The answer is quite simple: Food.

Sea lions have been making the long journey up the Columbia River long before the arrival of Europeans in the region, all on a mission to devour migrating fish that get crowded downstream of natural waterfalls. Lewis and Clark noted thousands of California and Stellar sea lions basking in the sun and devouring large runs of salmon at Celilo Falls more than 200 miles from the mouth of the Columbia River.

With the arrival of European settlers and the fur trade in the Pacific Northwest, sea lion populations declined to drastically low levels. Sea lions became less frequent at Celilo Falls, but native tribes continued to capture the densely packed salmon populations from fishing platforms that adorned the rock outcroppings. However, all of this was lost in the 1950s when The Dalles Dam and reservoir were constructed, submerging the falls under more than 40 feet of water.

Celilo Falls

With the introduction of the Marine Mammal Protection Act in 1972, sea lion populations began to rise from historically low levels of 10,000 to more than 300,000 individuals at today’s estimates. With the rebound of sea lion populations, more and more sea lions are seen each year making their way back up the Columbia River.

Bonneville Dam is the most downstream dam on the Columbia River, and has become the “new” Celilo Falls, or place for sea lions to congregate as they follow the migrating Coho, Chinook, Pink and Chum salmon, Stealhead Trout, and White Sturgeon. There is strong concern that the depressed salmon and sturgeon populations are not able to sustain significant predation from recently returning sea lions.  Recent studies indicate that sea lions are consuming anywhere from 1.7% to 4.7% of migrating salmon.

Sea Lion Sturgeon

Similarly, in the mid 1990s sea lions started following steelhead populations to the Ballard Locks outside of Seattle, leading to the decimation of the steelhead population.  Measures were taken to reduce the number of sea lions, with mixed results.

Numerous attempts have been made to deter sea lions from eating the fish at Bonneville Dam, including hazing techniques by native tribes. Despite these efforts, sea lions continue to consume threatened and endangered salmon, therefore government agencies have determined that the sea lion populations must be controlled in this region. Marine mammals are protected under the Marine Mammal Protection Act, therefore, federal approval was needed to supersede this Act and control sea lion Populations at Bonneville Dam, all in the name of increasing threatened and endangered salmon populations.

In 2008, government agencies were given clearance to euthanize up to 93 problematic California sea lions per year that meet the following criteria:

The States (Oregon, Washington, and Idaho) may lethally remove individually identifiable predatory California sea lions that are having a significant negative impact on Endangered Species Act-listed salmonids that:

a) have been observed eating salmonids at Bonneville Dam, in the “observation area” below the dam, in the fish ladders, or above the dam, between January 1 and May 31 of any year;

b) have been observed at Bonneville Dam on a total of any 5 days (consecutive days, days within a single season, or days over multiple years) between January 1 and May 31 of any year; and

c) are sighted at Bonneville Dam after they have been subjected to active non­lethal deterrence.

Through 2013, 45 sea lions were euthanized and another 13 were sent to zoos and aquariums, including the Queens Zoo in New York and the Shedd Aquarium in Chicago.

 

Several groups have questioned the utility of euthanization as a proper method to increase fish populations. They argue that human impacts, including dams, habitat destruction, as well as recreational and commercial harvest, are the main culprits for depressed fish populations. Further, many question the branding methods used to meet the qualification that all sea lions must be “individually identified”. The program as a whole has not been without mishaps.

Sea Lion Branding

With the ongoing migration of salmon up the Columbia River, sea lions are already gathering at the mouth of the Columbia River in Astoria.  This year is projected to bring the highest return of salmon to the Columbia River since records were started in 1938, and many wonder if that will also bring larger than normal populations of sea lions.

The program for euthanizing sea lions generally starts in April when sea lions that fit the above criteria are captured.  People are calling for improved solutions to this issue, yet at this time, the number of sea lions that fit the criteria are growing.  The current Federal approval for culling sea lions expires in 2016, and it appears that the current program will continue until that time.  To follow all the action, tune into the bi-weekly reports from Robert Stansell, who reports that as of March 20, 2014, there are few sea lions at the Bonneville Dam and they have witnessed very low predation on salmon and sturgeon (lowest since 2002).

Be sure to follow The Fisheries Blog on Facebook and on Twitter (@FisheriesBlog).

Sea Lion Consumption TableSea Lion Salmon Graph

Advertisements

14 responses to “Killing sea lions to save salmon

  1. Culling one species that is behaving normally within its native range in order to lessen predation on species imperiled by our own actions (at a bottleneck of our own creation) seems to be a bit of a bandaid. What efforts are being considered for dam modification or enhancing fish passage at such bottlenecks?

    • Or, in addition to what Ed suggested to address fish passage issues, what about looking at reducing the impact of harvest conducted by humans? Humans in the Columbia River Basin sure do catch a lot more salmon than a few sea lions do…

  2. The author writes: “Sea lions have been making the long journey up the Columbia River long before the arrival of Europeans in the region…Lewis and Clark noted thousands of California and Stellar sea lions basking in the sun and devouring large runs of salmon at Celilo Falls more than 200 miles from the mouth of the Columbia River.” Please post a peer-reviewed source for these assertions rather than a letter to the editor by a self-proclaimed expert. Please tell your readers why, if there were thousands of sea lions at Celilo Falls, they do not occur in the archeological record (see Lyman et al. 2002. Northwestern Naturalist, Vol. 83, No. 1, pgs. 1-6: “Prehistoric Occurrence of Pinnipeds in the Lower Columbia River”). Given that this blog appears to be to written by and for scientists, I would have expected such a complex sociopolitical and ecological issue as that which is going on in the Columbia River to be treated with a little more rigor and depth than it has here.

  3. Will your garden cuban humor of aphids to eat orr parasitise
    your greenhouse is a great weekend! This style oof cure. Once you have no idea how I got into bugs and
    it is thhe buzz word in today’s modern automobile.

  4. When you are a sizable cellular, seafch for those greater
    then you definitely regarding leaderboard.

  5. Please do not misunderstand my opinions on Justin Bieber-I am not a
    Bieber hater or something of the kind, and I believe folks spend
    entirely an excessive amount of time discussing him and different
    pop stars; I merely want to touch upon the qualities of this music.
    I have an insider e-mail list where I ask to your assist to elucidate pop songs and allow you to know about new
    posts and podcasts.

  6. The Church of England undertook the task of translating the Bible and in 1611; the Approved King James Bible was full.

    The Authorized King James Bible was actually the third
    English translation, following the Great Bible and the Bishop’s Bible.

  7. five hundrednuclear familyrevolting disgustingCuandonuclear familytwo twonuclear familyarrancamos five hundredextended familyrevolting disgustinglosfive
    hundred nuclear familyrevolting disgustingproyectosrevolting disgustingtwo five hundredextended familyrevolting disgustingdeextended familytwofive hundred five hundredtwoReformasrevolting disgustingextended familytwo five hundredextended familyrevolting disgustingIntegralesnuclear familyfive hundred, extended familynosnuclear family twonuclear familyreunimosrevolting disgustingnuclear familytwo five hundrednuclear
    familyconrevolting disgustingtwofive hundred tworevolting disgustingelextended familytwo five hundredrevolting disgustingclienteextended family five hundredparanuclear
    familytwo five hundredextended familyrevolting disgustingverrevolting disgustingfive hundred twoextended
    familysusextended familyfive hundred twonuclear familynecesidadesfive hundred nuclear familyrevolting disgustingyaextended familytwo nuclear familyquenuclear family extended familytendremosrevolting disgustingnuclear familyfive hundred
    twoextended familyrevolting disgustingquerevolting disgusting five hundredtwoextended familyrevolting disgustingrealizarfive hundred revolting disgustingun five hundredextended
    familygirorevolting disgustingnuclear family revolting disgustingderevolting disgustingnuclear
    familyfive hundred 180 twoextended familyrevolting disgustinggradosnuclear family
    five hundredtwonuclear familyenrevolting disgustingtwofive hundred five hundrednuclear familyrevolting disgustingsurevolting disgustingextended familytwofive hundred
    native five hundredtwonuclear familyrevolting disgustingviviendatwo.

  8. I simply could not go away the website prior to recommending that I actually loved the standard info
    an individual provide in your visitors? I’m certainly going to be back frequently in order
    to investigate unique content articles.

  9. I was very pleased to find this website. I need
    to to thank you for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely liked every little
    bit of it and i also have you book marked to see new stuff in your blog.

  10. Killing sea lions is ridiculous, and actually would not surprise me, as it is continuing the destruction of our environment that seems to be our goal as human beings. Leave them alone. They are doing what they are supposed to, instinctively.

Please leave a thought provoking reply. We reserve the right to remove comments deemed inappropriate.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s